I have been involved with PPA for several years and a member of the board of trustees for more than a year. Charity Navigator's (2011) rating of PPA is out of date and completely inconsistent with the organization that I know. In my view it is a five star organization. If you are interested in supporting ongoing protection of New Jersey's Pine Barrens, which remains threatened by development, then PPA is a very worthwhile organization to support. If you have any questions about Charity Navigator's current rating, please contact PPA's Executive Director Carleton Montgomery. PPA is completely transparent about its funding sources and operations, and a very active board has oversight and input on all aspects of the organization.