My Nonprofit Reviews

beasinthearmy - charity reviews, charity ratings, best charities, best nonprofits, search nonprofits

beasinthearmy

170 profile views
2 reviews

Review for Community Alliance for the Ethical Treatment of Youth, NY, NY, USA

Rating: 1 stars  

I am following up to my previous review of CAFETY.

As one of the founding members and former board member, I really started volunteering when I returned from Iraq. I spent much of my own money to get CAFETY started, the money I had saved from being shot at for a year. I continue to be disappointed with their performance, and I currently regret having spent so much of my own time and money to start such an organization.

One of the CAFETY board members, Nick Wood, contacted me asking to take down the only honest review of their organization on this website. I will let you, the reader, decide whether or not it is appropriate for someone to perform such an action. Nick Wood presented no evidence to refute any of the facts I presented in my previous review. He merely engaged in a standard "it's for the children" plea. I do not buy it, because these places have been in operation for decades and CAFETY has not done anything to save any kids.

In regards to their blatent partisanship, let's take for example, CAFETY's position on Bain Capital owning the Aspen Educational Group. Romney, as former director of Bain, is often demonized by CAFETY, as you can see from a search of their website (http://www.cafety.org/component/search/bain%20capital/?ordering=&searchphrase=all). However, there is no mention of the $417,000 that Bain Capital gave to the Obama campaign, nor the $5 million given to other Democrats (Source:http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/09/13/bain-capital-donations-democrats_n_1881655.html)

Will you volunteer or donate to this organization beyond what is required of board members?

No

How much of an impact do you think this organization has?

A little

Will you tell others about this organization?

Unlikely

When was your last experience with this nonprofit?

2013

Role:  Board Member
 

Review for Community Alliance for the Ethical Treatment of Youth, NY, NY, USA

Rating: 2 stars  

After reading all the dishonest reviews, I decided to get on here and write a real one. First, this organization should be converted from a 501 (c) 3 into a PAC. They spend more time criticizing Mitt Romney for a vague and loose connection to two people who did bad things. Romney's connection to these people is less than Obama ties to terrorists like Bill Ayers and Bernadine Dorn. Second, they are hyper-partisan, hence their campaigns like "Occupy JRC" and their affinity to protests for a day. Third, their finances are not tracked or monitored closely at all. Since I stepped away in 2009, their financial house has become a complete mess and thousands of dollars have gone missing.

If I had to make changes to this organization, I would...

prevent decisions being made from a partisan viewpoint and actually look at the issues from a neutral perspective, instead of from a progressive-socialist view.

Will you volunteer or donate to this organization beyond what is required of board members?

No

How much of an impact do you think this organization has?

A little

Will you tell others about this organization?

Likely

When was your last experience with this nonprofit?

2012

How did you learn about this organization?

Helped start it in 2006.

What is this organization's top short-term priority?

Stop Mitt Romney from being elected

What is its top priority in the long run?

Have the United States cede sovereignity to the United Nations.

Role:  Board Member & Treasurer 2006 to 2009.
kat_ (Nonprofit Staff) wrote:

Beas, As CAFETY's Director I take your assertion that "thousands of dollars have gone missing" and that our "financial house has become a complete mess" very seriously. At the time you were a board member, up until 2009, our fiscal affairs were administered by our fiscal sponsors at the National Youth Rights Association. Then, like now, our finances were tracked closely and may be found at link below. Your assertions are not based in fact and I'm actually not sure why you would ever present them as such, but should you have such concerns I advise you file a complaint to someone who can verify the accuracy of your allegations. Having personally worked along side the CAFETY Board in monitoring our finances closely and worked closely with our Administrative Director to ensure we meet our fiduciary duties, I am incredibly disappointing to see you make public comments of fiscal malfeasance or nonfeasance which, given the choice of forum, appears to be a decision not at all based on an interest of accountability, but an interest in undermining our hard work. http://www.cafety.org/component/content/article/817 Your other concerns appear to be simply strategy choices CAFETY has made that you don't agree with. However, again, you make serious allegations that are simply untrue. Contrary to your claims, our activities would never qualify as those activities permissible only to a entity formed as a PAC. We are not and have never been a partisan organization. We have never endorsed nor opposed any candidate running for office or any particular political party. We greatly value and welcome the need for external systems of accountability - both of us and of residential programs. Facts give us something to work with. Rumor and innuendos do not. If you are indeed acting in good faith, please take a moment to file the details of your concerns with the proper authorities. We would be happy to publish their findings.